VIDRRVictorian Institute forDisaster Research & Resilience
Menu

H5 course information

H5 COURSE · OPTIONAL RESEARCH MODULE · 30 MINUTES

Survival, Biological Change & Ecological Resilience

Explore what emerging research can tell us about birds that survive H5 infection, and why an individual survivor is only one part of the story of ecological recovery. Northern gannets provide a case study in interpreting biological change without confusing it with adaptation or guaranteed protection.

Research reviewed 28 October 2026. This extension sits alongside the four-hour assessed course and is not required for its certificate.

Guided learning: 12 minutes · evidence exercise: 10 minutes · reflection and self-check: 8 minutes. Full papers are optional further reading beyond this allocation.

Learning objectives

  • Distinguish individual survival, immune responses and population-level recovery.
  • Explain what darkened irises in northern gannets may indicate and what they cannot establish.
  • Interpret breeding findings and biological changes without assuming an adaptive benefit.
  • Communicate emerging research responsibly in an Australian wildlife-volunteering context.

1. What do we mean by resilience?

For this module, individual recovery means a bird survives illness and resumes activities. Population recovery concerns survival, recruitment and breeding across many birds and seasons. Ecological resilience asks a broader question: can populations and their ecological relationships persist or recover after disturbance? These are connected but different scales of evidence.

A photograph of one apparently healthy survivor cannot answer all three questions. Ask what was measured, in which species, at which site and over what period. A claim about an individual needs different evidence from a claim that a colony or ecosystem has recovered.

2. The northern gannet eye-colour case study

Lane and colleagues reported H5 antibodies in apparently healthy northern gannets after the major North Atlantic outbreaks. Many sampled survivors had unusually dark irises instead of the typical pale blue. This supported survival after infection and suggested a visible marker of past exposure. The iris is the coloured tissue around the pupil, not the pupil itself. [1]

Petalas and colleagues studied 65 adult gannets at Bonaventure Island, Canada, in 2023, publishing their findings in September 2026. Greater irregular iris pigmentation was associated with antibody evidence of previous avian-influenza exposure, more strongly for influenza A nucleoprotein antibodies than for H5 antibodies. The birds were deliberately sampled across eye appearances, so the sample is not a random estimate of colony-wide prevalence. [2]

The authors discuss inflammation and changes in iris pigment as possible contributors. This is a biological change, not evidence that darker eyes improve survival. Their antibody tests cannot by themselves establish the precise infecting strain or its pathogenicity. Eye appearance is a research clue, not a stand-alone diagnostic test, proof of infectiousness or proof of immunity. [2]

Source 1: further reading

Source 2: further reading

3. Can survivors breed again?

Lewis and colleagues followed northern gannets at Bass Rock and Bempton Cliffs in the 2023 breeding season. They found no clear difference in breeding success between black-eyed and blue-eyed birds, while overall breeding success remained below historical levels. This is encouraging evidence about some survivors, alongside continuing concern about colony recovery. [3]

Eye colour was a proxy for past exposure, not a complete infection history for every bird. Similar observed breeding success does not establish identical health, lifelong fitness or absence of delayed effects. Nor does it show that all bird species will respond similarly. [3]

Source 3: further reading

4. Survival, immunity and adaptation are different claims

Antibodies indicate an immune response to exposure. They do not alone demonstrate complete, lifelong protection against every future virus variant. APHA's early seabird research highlighted uncertainty about changing viruses, waning antibodies and protection of future offspring. [4]

Calling a change an adaptation makes a stronger claim than observing it. To argue that darkened irises are an adaptive benefit, researchers would need evidence that the trait improves a relevant outcome and a design that separates the trait from other explanations. An association with previous infection does not show that the eye change caused survival.

Useful next questions include: Do pigmentation changes persist? Are there lasting effects on vision, behaviour or survival? How does protection vary across species and later exposures? Keep these as research questions rather than filling the gaps with reassuring assumptions.

Source 4: further reading

5. From individual survivors to ecological recovery

Read breeding results alongside repeated counts, adult survival, recruitment, food availability and habitat conditions. A colony can contain successful survivors while remaining much smaller or producing fewer young. Long-term monitoring helps distinguish a temporary improvement from sustained recovery.

For an Australian learning context, the northern gannet evidence is a case study, not a validated eye-colour rule for Australasian gannets, pelicans, swans or other native birds. DCCEEW assesses vulnerability using species and ecological characteristics, reinforcing the need for locally relevant evidence. [5]

Use current agency instructions and your organisation's authorised role. Do not approach, catch or handle a bird to inspect its eyes or obtain a better photograph. Do not infer that an apparently recovered bird is safe to handle. Research observations do not replace reporting, biosecurity or veterinary assessment.

Source 5: further reading

APPLY YOUR LEARNING · 10 MINUTES

Turn a hopeful headline into an evidence-based explanation

Fictional scenario: A volunteer group shares a photograph with the caption, 'Black-eyed birds have adapted to H5 and are now immune. Our local colony will recover naturally.' You have been asked to help prepare a short, accurate response.

  1. Separate the caption into claims about eye colour, immunity, adaptation and colony recovery.
  2. Use the study summaries to identify which claims have some support and which go beyond the evidence.
  3. Name two observations researchers would need over time to assess population recovery.
  4. Write a three-sentence response that acknowledges hope, states a limitation and preserves safe volunteer behaviour.

Use your own notes. Personal disclosure is not required and your responses are not uploaded.

Review your response

A defensible response might say: 'Research on northern gannets suggests that some birds survive infection and breed again, and that altered iris pigmentation can be associated with past exposure. Eye colour does not establish lasting immunity, an adaptive advantage or recovery of an Australian colony. We can support authorised monitoring while continuing to follow current reporting and biosecurity instructions.' For population recovery, consider repeated breeding and survival measurements, recruitment and colony counts rather than a single photograph.

Check your understanding

Answer each prompt before opening the discussion.

Does a dark iris show that a bird has evolved greater resistance?

No. It may be associated with past exposure in the studied northern gannets. That does not establish a beneficial adaptation, heritability or resistance to reinfection.

If black-eyed and blue-eyed birds breed similarly, has the colony recovered?

Not necessarily. Compare the colony's overall breeding output, abundance and survival over time. Similar outcomes between observed groups can coexist with a population decline.

Should a volunteer move closer to inspect a bird's eye colour?

No. Stay within authorised observation arrangements and current agency directions. An eye-colour observation cannot establish diagnosis or handling safety.

Further reading

Follow the original publications for methods and limitations. These links do not imply endorsement of VIDRR.

Australian Government guidance · DCCEEW

5. Understanding the risk to native species

Australian context for species vulnerability. Check the live page and linked official updates before operational decisions.

Return to H5 course information